Fifth Circuit Rules That Clean Water Isn't a Constitutional Right, Keeps Residents Thirsty
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has officially declared that clean drinking water is not a constitutional right, a stunning affirmation of the long-held suspicion that your basic hydration needs are simply not a governmental priority. In a decision that could only be described as bureaucratically confident, Judge Kurt Engelhardt noted that while Jackson's residents may be suffering from lead-laden tap water, their plight does not infringe upon what he termed "deeply rooted constitutional rights." Apparently, those rights only cover things like freedom of speech and the right to bear armsβdrinking water, not so much.
Engelhardtβs ruling came in response to a lawsuit filed by Jackson residents, who alleged that the city knowingly allowed them to drink water that could potentially lead to brain damage. The judge was unmoved, arguing that the Constitution "does not provide redress for every governmental wrongdoing." Instead, he reassured the plaintiffs that while the contamination was undoubtedly grievous, they were not entitled to truthful information from their representatives during a public health crisis. This is a refreshing new bar for government transparency: if itβs toxic, just keep it quiet.
Still Beats Watergate:
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
In a dramatic twist, Engelhardt's court also asserted that citizens living in a place with an 80 percent Black population and poverty rates skyrocketing above the national average should take solace in the fact that other nations, like Uruguay and South Africa, have enshrined the right to clean water in their constitutions. In Jackson, however, the message is clear: survival of the fittest applies, and if your city government has been neglectful, well, that's just part of the American experience. The ruling seems to suggest that Jacksonians can either drink up or adapt to a life of extreme hydration innovation, perhaps through creative uses of bottled water.
Local Officials' Mismanagement Exposed
Meanwhile, frustratingly for residents, the city has issued a series of boil-water notices—a practice intended to address bacterial contamination but which ironically has the side effect of increasing lead concentrations, demonstrating that local officials have mastered the art of complicating an already dire situation. While officials at the Mississippi State Department of Health sat on their hands for six months after discovering lead levels exceeding acceptable limits, residents were left to drink the poisoned elixir that flowed from their taps.
Affecting you
But don't worry! The Trump Administration is hard at work diluting clean water protections, ensuring that the next generation will have an even harder time obtaining safe drinking water. It seems the EPA is more interested in crafting rules that appease their lobbyist friends than actually cleaning up the water supply. As Jim Murphy from the National Wildlife Federation pointed out, the administration's struggle to create a solid rule that balances environmental protection with donor satisfaction means that Jackson's residents might want to invest in a good filtration system—if they can afford one, that is.
In conclusion, as Jackson's residents face the ongoing threat of lead poisoning, the Fifth Circuit Court has added a new layer of irony to the American legal landscape: if you want clean water, you better be prepared to fight for it, but don’t expect any help from the courts. So, here’s to the brave citizens of Jackson! May your thirst drive innovation in hydration while we wait for the government to catch up with the rest of the world in protecting a basic human right.





