Court Rules Trump Administration Unlawfully Appointed Nevada's Top Prosecutor
A federal appeals court has made a historic decision by affirming that Sigal Chattahβs appointment as Nevadaβs top federal prosecutor was not just unlawful; it was a masterclass in bureaucratic overreach. The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Justice Department cannot simply will a prosecutor into existence through clever maneuvering and vague interpretations of the Federal Vacancies Reform Act. This ruling has thrown three ongoing criminal cases into legal limbo, leaving the stateβs legal system grappling with the question of who, exactly, is in charge.
The court determined that the Justice Department's efforts to keep Chattah in her position after her interim appointment expired were akin to trying to stretch a rubber band beyond its breaking point. When Chattah resigned her interim role just days before her 120-day term was up, the Justice Department believed it could magically conjure her back into power by designating her as first assistant U.S. attorney. This, they argued, would allow her to serve as acting U.S. attorney without any pesky Senate confirmation.
Still Beats Watergate:
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
However, the court was not having any of it. In a unanimous decision, the panel concluded that the Attorney General cannot simply create a de facto Acting U.S. Attorney by delegating responsibilities to someone who is not officially in that role. Judge Eric Miller, who was appointed by Trump himself, noted that such a move would be akin to allowing a magician to make a rabbit disappear and reappear at will.
As Chattah’s interim term approached its end last summer, then-Attorney General Pam Bondi’s decision to appoint her as first assistant was met with skepticism, especially after federal public defenders argued that her authority was as solid as a house of cards. The court agreed, highlighting that a first assistant can only step up as acting U.S. attorney if they are in the position at the moment the vacancy occurs.
This ruling is not only a setback for the Trump administration but a wake-up call for those who believe appointments can bypass standard procedures. As the administration continues to face court challenges regarding its attempts to sidestep Senate confirmation processes, one has to wonder how many more legal acrobatics will be attempted before someone suggests they just follow the rules.
In a final twist, it appears that Chattah may not even have been in the running for the permanent position as Trump has chosen George Kelesis to fill the role instead. This latest court ruling serves as yet another reminder that while the Trump administration may have a flair for dramatic appointments, the courts are here to remind them that legality still matters, even in the swirling chaos of Washington politics. With each setback, the administration’s talent for creative appointments seems to be getting more elaborate, yet less effective, leaving many to speculate on what absurdities might unfold next.





